He that writes to himself writes to an eternal public. -Emerson

Friday, November 3, 2023

The Deepest Fake

Faking it.

The generative artificial intelligence commonly in use today relies on machine learning models that express preexisting patterns in data of a particular type. Large language models of the sort that power ChatGPT, for example, express patterns found in language. Some of these patterns are well understood, some are tacit but obvious, and some surprise us altogether. That ChatGPT produces grammatical outputs is a requirement. That it apes formulaic documents such as Christmas Letters is no surprise. But that it can speak with the voice of a trusted friend is unexpected, and maybe unwelcome.

Generative AI capable of creating trusty outputs has been demonstrated in a variety of "modes": text, image, video. It seems a safe bet that anything that can be encoded as data can be synthesized in this fashion, and we have been encoding things since the invention of the punch card. There is a lot of data out there, and much of the activity in AI circles today is focused on "acquiring" specific datasets for this purpose (hence my current job title). Data acquisition has its challenges, but it's another safe bet that anything we really want encoded as data for model training can be so encoded, so acquired, and so modeled.

Current thinking states that the more data, the more powerful the model that can be made of it. There is a lot of fine print here, but nothing yet that invalidates this rule of thumb. And since data is often a direct function of time--that is, to get more data you can take more time to collect it--we can postulate that the larger the timespan considered, the more powerful the model that results. And if you want a larger timespan you have two choices: you can wait for time to go by, or you can mine the past.

Harvesting data from the past is a core occupation of economists, climate modelers, and, of course, historians. I anticipate that it will increasingly be the focus of AI developers as well. And, whatever their intentions, as they train more models on more historical data our communal capacity to generate outputs that look like artifacts of the past will increase.

You have, I trust, read 1984, in which the main character is employed by the Ministry of Truth to refabulate historical documentation. Orwell depicts this process as highly manual, a craft really, requiring careful manipulation of physical artifacts and the filing systems of giant bureaucracies. He also imagines it as carried out by a central authority working to a monolithic plan. In a digital world and with the new generative tools at hand, history will be faked by uncountable independent operatives working to their own idiosyncratic plans.

While there is widespread concern about the use of deepfakes to create competing narratives of current events (here's one recent example), the possibility of likewise manufacturing evidence to support competing narratives of historical events is less well recognized. There is, I think, a naive assumption that over time the truth will out. My concern is that the opposite will happen, with the past becoming increasingly uncertain and contentious as historical deepfakes proliferate.

As a (mostly non-practicing) professional historian I applaud the continued reevaluation of the past. History is constantly being rewritten, which is as it should be: new historians, with new perspectives and new tools, revisit old material and this changes history. In fact, new historical source material is discovered with some regularity, and AI is an increasingly important part of that process. Again, as it should be.

But there is a great difference between historians rewriting history and conspiracy theorists doing so. Both have an agenda--historians should never be treated as objective observers--but a properly trained historian is aware of this and uses rules of evidence and documentation that, say, Holocaust deniers merrily skip by. Professional historians also tend to write books and to publish in accredited journals, both of which, even today, usually appear in printed form, which is to say as durable, difficult to corrupt (though not impossible: see photo, above) records.

But a lie, famously, runs around the globe seven times while you're using inter-library loan to find the historical truth. And in the new age of generative history those lies are going to get better and better, and more and more numerous, and faster, too. And this while fewer and fewer of us are even trying to check a paper-encoded version. No answers here, just another plea to support your local library (and, post-publication, a Times piece that offers some suggestions).

Saturday, May 20, 2023

Dear Talia, here is your 50th birthday card

You are cute and tough and unfussy and strong and opinionated and beautiful and adventurous and well traveled and a great friend and you smell good and you party and you like to drive and you photograph well and your attractive children look like you. Also, you are an eater and a reader and an athlete and brave. You are good with babies and you are adorable and you are warm in bed and and you know what you like and you are not unwilling to look foolish and you are a good daughter-in-law. You are loyal and a very good parent and you are ridiculously popular and I love your smile and you have excellent taste in clothes and know what metadata is. You can carry a lot and you mix a good martini and are not afraid to get your hands dirty and you have great feet and you make eye contact and you do more than your fair share and don't even get me started about your figure. And you are tolerant to a point and you dance and you love to camp and you will go anywhere and you are cool and know interesting people and you are aging beautifully and you think for yourself and you love to cook and are good at it. Most important, and most you, you have the biggest biggest heart. The proof is right here: in hundreds of pictures there is love in your eyes. I can blog and one day may even say it: I am so grateful to have you as my partner in this life and to have already had so many years with you. Happy Birthday, wonderful you.



Sunday, May 14, 2023

Mother love

 

My mother loved me. That is a central fact of my life and, I hope, of yours: a parent's love, perhaps even two. 

My mother was also a source of great irritation to me. I love my children. I am also a source of great irritation to them. Irritation is an inevitable side effect of being close--we are none of us perfectly smooth. But the irritation a child feels toward a parent is, I think, often a direct product of the parent's love, of having someone else care as much or even more than you yourself do about your successes and your failures, about your actions and decisions, about your hurts and healing. It is deeply intrusive, thus, again, irritating.

Irritation demands a response. Many children respond to the irritation of a parent's love by taking space from it, or trying to. It is part of what makes the teen years so fractious: the desire to take space is there, the ability to do so is limited. Later, we move, leaving our parents behind with their love. But absence, they say, only makes the heart grow fonder. A terrifying thought.

I left my mother and now, many decades later, she has left me. Still, my mother loved me, and that fact remains.

Saturday, March 18, 2023

Found art

Gid's bestie took these voice clips from his voicemail, set them to music and video clips, and turned them in for an English assignment. I trust he got an A. I don't know what Gid did for this same assignment.


I think this is an homage, but note that the friend's updated voicemail greeting specifically requests that if the caller is Gideon, he not leave a message. Too much of a good thing, I guess.

Friday, February 10, 2023

Aging

We all fall down

As adults, we get older, for the most part, without really noticing it. Yes, I recognize I am fifty-whatever, but I don't see a lot of difference between fifty this and fifty that, or even forty something. The milestones of birthdays have long since lost their meaning, becoming just another day in which we are fractionally creakier than we were the day before.

So I am surprised to find myself suddenly feeling distinctively older than I have ever felt before. It is the unwelcome product of a bunch of unwelcome events. It started when I broke my collarbone playing in the Pacific surf some weeks ago. That was debilitating and though I think I am healing well, I am not the same. I'm also recovering from COVID, my first bout and not a terrible one by that yardstick, but draining. Isolation, bed time, it makes you feel smaller.

But it's not just health. In the midst of this I traveled to help with my mother, who was very sick and who died within a week of this last visit to her. That death obviously contributes to this feeling, but so did watching my siblings cope with that, and so does watching the family plan the funeral and make the arrangements. Funerals have before always been something to attend, not something to make decisions about.

The kids are great, but college looms, forcing we parents to think about time and its passage and the future and its implications. And the kids aren't just great, they're also challenging, and not in that simple why-won't-you-leave-me-alone-for-a-minute way they were when they were younger. Really challenging. Like, "we parents need to think about this and when we do we don't necessarily come up with the right response" challenging, not suddenly but quite pointedly at the moment.

And then there are the projects, or rather, Projects. Each is so big, and they all require management and money, and they come, as the picture above suggests, pell-mell and not necessarily when you have the capacity to deal with them. And, for us, they inevitably include lots of time spent wrestling with bureaucracy and that shit does not make you feel any more alive.

And for some reason there are lots of spiders around these days. Really big ones.

Aging happens gradually, silently for the most part, but sometimes it happens with an audible "snap."